So long, and thanks for all the fish?…

Tomorrow morning, around 0630 GMT (0230 Bda time), we’ll get the final results of the Scottish independence referendum – and we’ll know whether Scotland will begin its transition to independence in 2016, or a transition to devo-max (greater devolved powers, kind of like Bermuda has) within the UK itself.

I honestly have no idea what the result will be.  It’s far too close to call.  Way too close.

Photo credit to STV.

Photo credit to STV.

I have found the Yes (pro-independence) campaign to be invigorating and inspiring.  They have reawakened ideals of participatory democracy and civic nationalism.

I have found the No (anti-independence) campaign extremely disappointing and based largely on scaremongering.

That being said said, there are pros and cons to both sides.

Regardless of the result, I don’t think Scotland will go back to the political status quo.  The active and energised nature of the debate – of which the overwhelmingly No-siding UK media has not done justice in portraying – has radicalised and heightened political consciousness of a whole new generation.

Relying solely on the media portrayal of the campaign would give a very distorted impression of the realities on the ground.

I have not encountered any anti-English sentiment, and while I have encountered the occasional romantic idea of a reborn independent Scottish state, even those who’ve indulged in such notions have engaged in a critical review of the pros and cons of Scottish independence.

I have encountered, participated and observed random strangers on buses, trains and queues engage in passionate and informed discussions – with a surprising number even quoting page numbers from the several hundred page white paper on Scottish Independence in their exchanges!

It truly is amazing to hear random strangers, from across the social strata and occupations, discussing the minutiae of such obscure subjects as the Barnett Formula (the process by which the block grant, forming the Scottish Government’s budget, is allocated) or the consequences of the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership as regards privatisation (particularly of the NHS).

For anyone to try and dismiss the Scottish electorate as being uninformed or voting solely on emotion or in spite (of the English or the Tories) is to do an injustice to this exhilarating historic moment.

I hope that this phenomenon does not end with the Referendum.  I am hopeful that this newly engaged electorate continues to be engaged, regardless of the result.

I imagine a Yes vote will be the least divisive outcome – those who voted No would, for the most part, rally around in the interests of making an independent Scotland work.

A No vote, without radical restructuring of the UK state, will only postpone a future referendum and, ultimately, Scottish independence; it would be seen as a final chance for the UK.  The Yes voters will continue to agitate and hold the No promises to their word.  Despite an initial depression from Yes voters, this will just be temporary and a new generation of Yes activists will expand on the pro-independence arguments, setting the foundation for the future.

Ultimately, if Scotland hasn’t voted for independence today, without some very real and radical restructuring of the UK State, then Scottish independence is only a matter of time.  A No vote would only postpone the inevitable.

So, it really time to say so long, and thanks for all the fish?


On a side note, the turnout so far appears, from all accounts, to be record breaking.

I voted at 1930hrs GMT, and with two and a half hours still to go, at that time, before the polls closed, the agents were estimating that my polling station had already experienced an 80% turnout.  They were even suggesting they might make it to a 90% overall turnout in my area.

What does that mean for the overall result?

No idea.

We’ll find out tomorrow morning…

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “So long, and thanks for all the fish?…

  1. “Regardless of the result, I don’t think Scotland will go back to the political status quo”.

    I could not agree more.

    Whilst I want there to be a “no” vote for a whole boat load of reasons, you are absolutely correct to say that Scotland will not return to the status quo. And rightly so.

    The whole exercise will have sent a chilling message to the Conservatives in particular. Thatcher’s arrogance and almost dismissive attitude to Scotland still shows through today, and it will be the case that they pay a price whatever the outcome.

    So too might Labour of course, if there is a “yes” vote and Labour were also to win the next UK election but be left without a majority in early 2016.

    An interesting period ahead – irrespective of the outcome.

  2. Appreciate your thoughts and various links JS. I see the first result is in favoring no. How do you see this extrapolating for the remaining vote given your on the ground experiences?

  3. I was surprised at his decision – he’ll head up the negotiations for devo-max though, before he resigns (today was just a statement that he will be resigning).

    I think he can hold his head high – even though he lost, he, and Scotland, all won.

    Having said that, I am disturbed at a triumphalist Unionism manifesting itself with Nazi salutes, Loyalist imagery and thuggish attacks on Yes supporters. The revenge of ugly Unionism…

    http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/sep/19/violence-glasgow-scotland-loyalists-attack-independence-supporters

  4. “……….even though he lost, he, and Scotland, all won”.

    I suspect it’s more than just Scotland. Irrespective of the issue, it really was a day for the people everywhere, if people think about it.

    Woke a few politicians up, disturbed their smug, complacent world, and rattled a few cages which is a good thing at the end of the day.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s