Mr. Obama’s Speech

To begin with I acknowledge that I am no doubt a distinct minority in Bdian politics in my non-support for Barack Obama. It is no secret that almost the entire active (and most likely the general support base) of the PLP is very much pro-Obama, and it seems from my interaction with UBPers, as well as Christian’s many writings on his campaign, that a majority of the UBP are also pro-Obama. True, I have come across a handful, including at least one PLPer strangely enough, that are McCain supporters, and also some Hilary supporters.

I personally see little real difference between the two so-called Parties in the States, only two wings of one big corporate Party. Of the US Parties I am a supporter of the Socialist Party of the USA, and their Presidential campaign.

All the same, I found it necessary to comment on Mr. Obama’s speech the other day. There are a number of reasons for this. Namely, it is obvious how the UBPers will latch onto Mr. Obama’s political approach to race and attempt to echo this rhetoric in the Bdian context. Mr. Dunleavy has already begun just this, as evidenced in these two posts in regards to this speech. On the other hand I feel it is necessary to criticise those within the Party who have the mistaken (albeit in my view) perception of Mr. Obama as being something he is not, and whose support for him seems to be based more on uncritical identity politics than critical thought; much of what Mr. Obama advocates actually would lead them into even more doublethink than we currently have, an unfortunately high level as it is.

In the local context the UBP will respond willingly to Mr. Obama’s comments, just as many responded well to Mr. Cosby’s ‘Pound Cake Speech.’ In short, here is a black man saying what white people think. Of course I’m generalising here, but for the sake of argument, lets go with it. The exceptional thing of Mr. Obama’s campaign to date is his almost desparate attempt to portray himself as not black. The fact that he is black is taken for granted, and many in the African-American community have supported him more or less on this basis alone (I am basing this on personal discussions with Bdians, and from analysing commentaries from the US). But even with 100% Black support, Mr. Obama cannot win the Presidency. In order to win he must win the White vote. In order to do this he must adopt White positions. Otherwise, he risks alienating the white vote. It may be that Mr. Obama really truly believes in these positions, I am not questioning that. But it is also true that historically these positions he is taking have only found minority support within the African-American community.

Mr. Obama’s main message on race, if one reads it and actually stops to reflect on it, is basically to say that we are still dealing with the legacy of race, but talking about it oertly is tantamount to ‘politics of division.’ He actually doesn’t suggest how to overcome these legacies. He more or less applies some meaningless rhetoric, some soothing balm, to the consciences of White America. His message is essentially the same that the UBP appears to adhere to, talking about race is divisive, its time to move on. Nothing more than meaningless feel good rhetoric. Like Mr. Cosby’s speech this gives an outlet to many White American’s thoughts, soothed by the knowledge that this message was said by a Black man first.

What impact this will have on the majority of African-American’s is interesting as well. It is possible that with the mass media trumpeting this ‘White-friendly’ speech, combined with the desire for the very real symbolic potential that Mr. Obama represents, that those views previously held only by a minority of the African-American population, will gain wider support. It is also possible, especially with the mass media also showing snippets of the apparently ‘White-offensive’ speech of Reverend Wright (which forced Mr. Obama’s reply) that many in the African-American community will stop and reflect basically along the lines of ‘wait, Rev. Wright is right when you think about it’ and result in a backlash towards Mr. Obama amongst the African-American community.

I personally found myself agreeing with much of what Reverend Wright had stated. 9/11 was largely a result of ‘chicken’s coming home to roost’ as he put it, in reference to US imperialist support of state terrorism overseas (from Apartheid South Africa, to Apartheid Isreal-Palestine, to supporting Islamofascism throughout the Middle East against progressive leftist forces, to propping up dictators – like Saddam – during the Cold War, to funding, organising, training and facilitating Islamic terrorists in Afghanistan, Bosnia, Kosovo and Chechenya for example). The US was and continues to be what Martin Luther King Jr. described as ‘a democracy for the White and the rich, and a dictatorship for the Black and the poor.’

Of course, speaking truth to power, especially in a plutocracy such as the US with its electoral system essentially rigged to favour establishment candidates, is a sure fire way not to get elected. So I can completely understand why Mr. Obama says what he says, and I also have the belief that he often even believes most of the rhetoric he says, or wrote in his Audacity of Hope.

7 thoughts on “Mr. Obama’s Speech

  1. That is so true anout Obama, and Clinton for that matter.

    I know how empowering it can feel to say as a black American or a woman America “hey we just elected our first _______ president”, trust me, I really do, I would love to one day see an Indian president (I we are probably the least likely ethnic group to see a president elected though) but one must judge such a canidate based on what the person thinks, not just on how progressive it may be to have a black president.

    For me Obama would be just more of the same capitalist, imperialist bullshit we have had in the United States since 1783, but with a new handsome smiling face on it. Obama is an awsome orator, but that does not mean bunk in the long run, I can give lots of good examples of leaders who were great speakers but who had terrible policies. Obama will continue to keep the working class down, he does not advocate any sort of true universal health care, he will likely continue the war and the hawk rhetoric against America’s enemies (though it may be toned down a little), he will not dismantle nuclear arms, he will not do anything meaningful on climate change, he will not defend gay rights, likely wouldn’t do much to defend abortion, I dount he’ll repeal the patriot act or any other piece of government crap that has stripped the rights of Americans, and I doubt he will actually be any great uniter.

    Like I said before, more of the same but with a new face, just like Reagan.

  2. As an American, I liked Dennis Kucinich. He stood up for immediate end to the war, gay rights and a repeal of the Patriot Act. I would have even voted for Ron Paul. They were both too extreme and really didn’t have a chance. My point is that a politician has to be middle of the road in order to get the majority of people behind him, black and white.

    Why is everyone so concerned with race now? The economy is going down the drain, home foreclosures are up and commodity prices are through the roof but all we care about is race. What exactly is the “white talk” that Obama is speaking? I think right now regardless of race a lot of middle class people have the same concerns. I think Obama is speaking to that but he doesn’t have the political history of his competitors so people aren’t as jaded when they hear him speak. I think it says a lot because people have to become more interested in there government to make sure we don’t end up in another unethical war (i.e. Iran).

    What I dislike the most is the protection and lip service that the United States offers Israel. Presidential nominees have to support Israel and can’t criticize them because they have a lot of lobbyists employed who work solely for Israel’s interest. I will never understand why we are supporting another country who is militarily superior than any country in the middle east surrounding them. When a person speaks out, they instantly become anti-Semitic. It is supposed to be separation of Church and State but yet we use the Church to justify why we protect Israel. The United States gives them billions each year to commit outrages against the Palestinians. I will never understand why they are thought to be the Chosen People.

  3. My main problem with everything Obama said is that everytime in the US, and elsewhere, someone tries to call out white privilage for what it is, they are likened to some sort of race mongering psychopath.

    It seems the majority of U.S. populace would just like us to all hold hands and sing koombaya, like they just want us, the minorities to kindly forgive and forget. I have no problems forgiving (though not without some giving), but I see no reason why Indians, African-Americans, Latinos/Chicanos, Asians, Arabs etc should just say “oh well, the past it the past, we clearly still have most of the same problems as before, but Obama wants us to keep it to ourselves”

    It’s bullshit man, and that’s why I say Obama and the rest of the democrats are just more of the same shit as before. Screw Obama, Clinton and McCain, I’m voting Brian Moore & Stewart Alexander of SP-USA in November. Do I expect them to win? Not even in my dreams, but I know that I will not be wasting my vote on a fake canidate.

  4. Pingback: » POLL: Who do you think will win the US Election?

  5. Anytime Jonny. I read Obama’s speech myself and I found it amazingly eloquent. However (as I stated on another blog), I’m very concerned as to its timing. That puts a unwelcome blemish on what is essentially a stirring comment on social and racial problems.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s